Adobe CS3 Review Part 4: Flash Professional
July 27th, 2007This is the final installment of my multi-part review of Adobe’s new Creative Suite, CS3. In Part 1: Dreamweaver, I looked at how easy it was to get a basic Web site up without any prior training in using Dreamweaver and in Part 2: Illustrator I used the vector drawing application to very quickly and (relatively easily) produce a nice 3D logo for the new Web site. Part 3 saw me using Photoshop with the new CS3 application Device Central to produce a wallpaper graphic for the Motorola RAZR, and in this part I’ll…Well, I’m not sure. I have to admit that my “can a layman use it” theme of this review was always likely to be the most severely challenged by Flash CS3 Professional, the subject of the last part of this review. For a start, would the layman really want to use this application, so identified as it is with advanced Web development?
One thing that gave me hope is the fact that the Flash CS3 UI, in line with all the other CS3 applications, has had many changes to make it more standardized, including the introduction of the “panels” feature that I wrote about in Part 3. Also, thanks to YouTube, I know that Flash does video. I therefore decided to see if I could use Flash to create a nicely packaged introductory video for visitors to the Web site, the construction of which has been the subject of these reviews.
I took several wrong steps before consultation with some online tutorials revealed that it’s actually a separate application, Flash Video Encoder, that handles video encoding for Flash. I had a 45 second clip that would substitute for an introductory video and, after some cross platform trickery (not involving Flash) to get it from the Windows based AVI file format into the Mac based MOV format I simply dragged it into the Flash Video Encoder window, accepted the defaults for the “Flash 8 - Medium Quality” setting and hit the “Start Queue” button to encode it. To be honest, once the video was ready I really wasn’t sure what type of Flash Project to start when faced with the Welcome Screen on opening Flash, so I quit the application and opened the file directly, guessing that Flash would automatically open the right workspace for the file. This it did, after prompting me for the deployment format for the video. Having accepted the default “Progressive download from a web server” I was presented with a choice of “Skins”, or player designs, in which to present the video, and was able to customize the color of the skin by picking a Web safe color - very cool, and very easy. The final stage was the Finish Video Import dialogue box which is very verbose, and gives precise details of what file needs to be placed where in order for the video to work on your Web site, and also features a handy checkbox to view video topics in Flash Help when finished. After some fiddling with parameters via the Component Inspector and a number of false starts I was able to to publish the video and test it playing in a Web page.
Although I eventually produced something useable I have to say that Flash Professional, as I feared, ultimately proved too complex for layman’s use (or certainly this layman’s use). It took me much longer, many false starts and frequent references to the Help files and online resources to wrangle something useable, and my reluctant conclusion is that this application, at least, is better left to the professionals - hence the Flash Professional name, I guess.
Conclusions
So what have I proved from this series of reviews of some of the CS3 applications? Well hopefully I’ve shown that, excluding very specialist applications such as Flash Professional, the core Core CS3 applications that appear in most versions of the bundle: Adobe Photoshop CS3/CS3 Extended; Adobe Illustrator CS3; and Adobe Dreamweaver CS3, despite being powerful programs, are all usable by the non-specialist. Although the price for a small business ($1,599 for Creative Suite 3 Web Premium and $1,799 for Creative Suite 3 Design Premium, $999 and $1,199 respectively for the Standard editions) may seem high, especially for the smaller small businesses, it compares favorably with perhaps having to spend thousands of dollars on Web designers, especially if you have to keep going back to them for minor graphical tweaks/refreshes. Don’t get me wrong: I’m definitely an advocate for hiring professionals to do a professional job and I’m in no way recommending that small business owners should all try and put together their own Web sites. However, in reality many small businesses cannot afford to pay professionals to do everything and an investment in one of the CS3 Suites and some time spent learning the basics may produce something worthwhile until that business can afford to get a professional in.